Mendo I'm Calling you Out!

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

mendokuse wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

Anaki Uchiha wrote:

mendokuse wrote:

OK here's what I made.

picture 4.75/5
looks pretty good, just not completely anime-ish.didn't take much off though cause if you found it on deviantart, most of the stuff is like that.

text 4.75/5
the characteristics could be a little higher up and spaced, but other than that good.

Effect 5/5
I love the effect for this one. its original, not broken, and fits shika perfectly.

Overall 4.75/5
don't see much wrong. just fix up the little things and its good.

total: 19.25

how is the part with the picture fair? If he found a non-anime-ish picture and used it, take off for it. Don't go and just let him slide because he found it there and most of them aren't animeish...

I wouldnt complain your picture isn't exactly anime, its also a colored in manga pic yet you lost no points.

because it looks like it was from the anime, yours looks like a colored picture

well, if i did re-judge then the points I'd take off would only mean a tie on my end, which n4ever's judging would add to mendo still getting the win. so I guess either way the score is only like a single point difference at the most. good job both of you.