Shadow Shika vs. ??

So yeah, i wanna do another one...


Edit:
SPECIAL TOURNEY RULES:

• Judging Criteria:
  

  Spoiler:

• 2 Judges, judge 25 points each. Whoever makes it closest to 50 wins
  

Ok lets have a rematch?

naruto4ever wrote:

Ok lets have a rematch?

bring it on

HeHe......oh this will be good.

finished my card

Oh god i gotta post a card what to do what to do.

Some body order a open procter.

Well here is my card sorry for the wait i deserve to loose

[quote="Shadow Shikamaru"]finished my card


Picture: 4.5/5 Its placed in a good spot and the outline seems fine. Try to move it a little to the left.

Effect: 5/5 The effect seems to match the card alot.

Text: 5/5 All the text is up to date and matches bandai's.

Stats: 5/5 I see all the naruto's that have been maid always are -3/-0 for a healthy stats so your fine.

All togather: 4/5 Where the number is i see you maid a slight change to pit the "Set pic" in.

Total 23.5/25 Good job Shadow Shika

Picture: 4/5 The picture seems fine, looks a little cartoonish, but clear. I see that on the left side itachi is cut off, he can exceede the card at least.

Effect: 5/5 Matches the card, enough said.

Text: 5/5 Seems fine a little cracked but not broken.

All togather: 4/5 Stats were fine and rarity seems fine. Its just the pic was cut off.

Total: 23/25 Shadow Shika wins by a .5 lead but still both cards beat me by a lot.

oh yeah! Finally beat n4e in a match!

[quote="itachiforpresident6"]

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

finished my card


Picture: 4.5/5 Its placed in a good spot and the outline seems fine. Try to move it a little to the left.

Effect: 5/5 The effect seems to match the card alot.

Text: 5/5 All the text is up to date and matches bandai's.

Stats: 5/5 I see all the naruto's that have been maid always are -3/-0 for a healthy stats so your fine.

All togather: 4/5 Where the number is i see you maid a slight change to pit the "Set pic" in.

Total 23.5/25 Good job Shadow Shika

Few things you missed 1st the effect is SUPER BROKEN! so a 5/5 seems a bit wrong. Also Mendo is gonan judge still.

Okay, well naruto4ever pm'd me and told me to judge, so i will.

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

finished my card

Picture 5/5
seems perfect to me.

Quality 4.75/5
pretty good, it altogether seems like one of bandai's cards, although I think the characteristics should be moved down a little bit more.

text 5/5
well, all of the text seems close to bandais and is neat.

Effect 3.75/5
sorry, but the effect is pretty broken. Not only can they not be touched, but healthy or injured it's dealing damage nearly every turn to one of your oponents ninjas.

Overall 4/5
The card is really good. I think the only thing wrong is the effect. Maybe add a different first effect to balance it out and your good.

total: 22.5/25

[quote="naruto4ever"]

itachiforpresident6 wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

finished my card


Picture: 4.5/5 Its placed in a good spot and the outline seems fine. Try to move it a little to the left.

Effect: 5/5 The effect seems to match the card alot.

Text: 5/5 All the text is up to date and matches bandai's.

Stats: 5/5 I see all the naruto's that have been maid always are -3/-0 for a healthy stats so your fine.

All togather: 4/5 Where the number is i see you maid a slight change to pit the "Set pic" in.

Total 23.5/25 Good job Shadow Shika

Few things you missed 1st the effect is SUPER BROKEN! so a 5/5 seems a bit wrong. Also Mendo is gonan judge still.

No, no one else will judge because only 1 judge replied
therefore, I won
If I was not notified of judges, this is closed

[quote="Shadow Shikamaru"]

naruto4ever wrote:

itachiforpresident6 wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

finished my card


Picture: 4.5/5 Its placed in a good spot and the outline seems fine. Try to move it a little to the left.

Effect: 5/5 The effect seems to match the card alot.

Text: 5/5 All the text is up to date and matches bandai's.

Stats: 5/5 I see all the naruto's that have been maid always are -3/-0 for a healthy stats so your fine.

All togather: 4/5 Where the number is i see you maid a slight change to pit the "Set pic" in.

Total 23.5/25 Good job Shadow Shika

Few things you missed 1st the effect is SUPER BROKEN! so a 5/5 seems a bit wrong. Also Mendo is gonan judge still.

No, no one else will judge because only 1 judge replied
therefore, I won
If I was not notified of judges, this is closed

As far as i was aware it saied 2 judges on your first post. Mendo is to sick to judge so Anaki is judging. Also no offense to Itachiforprez6 your judging is a little rough. I should have lost poits in place as well as ShadowShikamaru. Also ShadowShikamaru you dont need to get defensive you could still win. So let Anaki judge and see what happens.

[quote="naruto4ever"]

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

naruto4ever wrote:

itachiforpresident6 wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

finished my card


Picture: 4.5/5 Its placed in a good spot and the outline seems fine. Try to move it a little to the left.

Effect: 5/5 The effect seems to match the card alot.

Text: 5/5 All the text is up to date and matches bandai's.

Stats: 5/5 I see all the naruto's that have been maid always are -3/-0 for a healthy stats so your fine.

All togather: 4/5 Where the number is i see you maid a slight change to pit the "Set pic" in.

Total 23.5/25 Good job Shadow Shika

Few things you missed 1st the effect is SUPER BROKEN! so a 5/5 seems a bit wrong. Also Mendo is gonan judge still.

No, no one else will judge because only 1 judge replied
therefore, I won
If I was not notified of judges, this is closed

As far as i was aware it saied 2 judges on your first post. Mendo is to sick to judge so Anaki is judging. Also no offense to Itachiforprez6 your judging is a little rough. I should have lost poits in place as well as ShadowShikamaru. Also ShadowShikamaru you dont need to get defensive you could still win. So let Anaki judge and see what happens.

guess you haven't ever noticed. He favors you over anybody else

Oh and next time, don't let me win with the wrong format of text

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

guess you haven't ever noticed. He favors you over anybody else

Oh and next time, don't let me win with the wrong format of text

Alright um thats not true. Also your text is formated correctly just spacing issues.

naruto4ever wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

guess you haven't ever noticed. He favors you over anybody else

Oh and next time, don't let me win with the wrong format of text

Alright um thats not true. Also your text is formated correctly just spacing issues.

Im talking about yours
the characteristics are too small...

naruto4ever wrote:

Well here is my card sorry for the wait i deserve to loose

Picture 4.75/5
its clear and fits good, except, in the left of the card, the cape could go over the card more.

Quality 4.75/5
practiclly perfect compared to bandai's, the effect box looks a little too dark though.

Text 5/5
all seems good to me.

Effect 5/5
seems good. its playable, useful, and fitting for an itachi.

Overall 4.25/5
it all seems good. i'm not sure about the flavor text, usually it has something about the effect, and the effect has nothing to do with him getting weaker, but thats not always the case. either way nice card like normal.

total: 23.75/25

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

naruto4ever wrote:

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

guess you haven't ever noticed. He favors you over anybody else

Oh and next time, don't let me win with the wrong format of text

Alright um thats not true. Also your text is formated correctly just spacing issues.

Im talking about yours
the characteristics are too small...

And that is where your wrong the Stats are the exact same size as they are on Itachi [GOAL]. Im not gonna argue either if your gonna be a poor sport about it then ill just say i give (note i have not stated that ia have YET). Your card has many things wrong with it that should be marked off for thats all im saying.

so shadow shikamaru total: 46/50

naruto4ever total: 46.75 if i counted right.

Well i think Shadow Shika won this i dont want to have any arguements on this site so i think ill give it to Shadow because well if an arguement sparks i dont want to have a possible ban if it gets bad enough.

I forfeit because naruto4ever gave me the win

Shadow Shikamaru wrote:

I forfeit because naruto4ever gave me the win

Call it a draw then.

naruto4ever wrote:

Well i think Shadow Shika won this i dont want to have any arguements on this site so i think ill give it to Shadow because well if an arguement sparks i dont want to have a possible ban if it gets bad enough.

well, you both did extremely good, and both of you are superb card makers. also shadow shika, i don't favor him over you or anything, your like one of my best freinds on this site, its not like i would take points off against your or add any to n4e because i thought he's better.(besides, all your cards still amaze me, I cant make a even near that good.)